client and attorney shaking hands

Resources, Education, & News Blog

$45 Million Verdict Secured for Victims of Hidden Cameras in Vacation Rental Case

In a groundbreaking privacy violation case, Ryan Beasley, Wes Few, and Debbie Barbier helped secure a monumental $45 million verdict for Heather and Gabriel Crespo. The couple was secretly recorded by South Carolina vacation property landlord Rhett C. Riviere during their stay in Aiken in 2001. This landmark ruling sends a powerful message about privacy violations and the severe consequences of such egregious disregard for contractual responsibility.

The Crespos rented a cottage from Riviere, unaware that hidden cameras had been installed in the bedroom and bathroom. Over two decades, Riviere recorded over 20,000 unsuspecting renters across multiple properties. These recordings, discovered years later, included intimate moments of the Crespos and other victims. In 2019, Riviere’s ex-fiancée found microSD cards containing the footage and handed them over to authorities, bringing these disturbing videos to light.

The selected jury delivered its verdict on September 25, 2024, awarding the Crespos $27 million in compensatory damages and an additional $18 million in punitive damages the following day. This case was not just about financial compensation. It was about revealing a gross invasion of privacy and sending a strong message to anyone who may think they can violate renters’ trust. Hidden cameras in vacation property rentals are a profound threat to everyone’s right to privacy, and the legal team stressed the broader implications of the case.

Courage and Accountability: The Crespos’ Fight for Privacy Rights

The legal team representing the Crespos emphasized Heather and Gabriel’s bravery in telling their story and holding Riviere accountable for his actions. They made it clear that this misconduct would not be tolerated. The severity of the damages awarded reflected how deeply the couple’s privacy had been violated.

Throughout the trial, the jury learned about Riviere’s pattern of behavior. He invoked his Fifth Amendment right when questioned about his finances and his involvement in distributing or selling the videos. Despite his silence, the jury’s verdict acknowledged the emotional distress and trauma caused by his actions.

The Crespos, who had no idea they were being filmed, only learned of the recordings in 2021. A South Carolina Law Enforcement Division (SLED) investigation revealed 3.7 terabytes of video data found while searching Riviere’s properties, including recordings from multiple rental homes and even hidden cameras aboard yachts.

The Importance of Privacy and Safety in Vacation Rentals

This case highlights the critical importance of safety and privacy for guests staying in vacation rentals. As these online platforms grow in popularity, renters must trust that their personal space is secure and that they are not subjected to unlawful surveillance. The Crespos’ courage in speaking out and the legal team’s efforts helped ensure that Riviere’s actions did not go unpunished.

Ryan Beasley, highly experienced in both criminal defense and civil litigation, played a crucial role in securing justice for the Crespos. His firm focuses on personal injury and privacy violation cases, offering legal guidance and protection for those facing similar situations. As the legal team emphasized during the trial, the emotional distress caused by such invasions of privacy can have lasting effects, making it crucial for those responsible to face significant consequences.

Criminal Case Verdict Delivers a Strong Message

The $45 million verdict not only represents a victory for the Crespos but also sends a clear warning to property owners within the vacation rental industry. Owners must be held accountable for ensuring the safety and privacy of their guests. This case underscores the need for thorough background checks and monitoring to prevent unethical or illegal actions.

At Ryan Beasley Law, we have extensive experience defending clients in criminal and civil litigation matters, including personal injury cases like this one. If you’re facing a situation involving privacy violations or other serious legal issues, we provide the direction and protection you need to confidently move forward. Call or fill out a contact form today to learn how Ryan Beasley Law can assist you.