Let's Change The Outcome

A sliding scale for criminal fines and traffic tickets?

To a brain surgeon or corporate executive, a speeding ticket is no big deal. They probably have that much cash in their purse or wallet. When a retail clerk or maid gets that traffic ticket, it hurts. It may mean the rent is late or they can’t buy food. It can have a domino effect.

Some countries have a sliding scale for criminal fines, based on the person’s income. That makes all citizens accountable and increases revenue. Should we be doing this in the U.S.?

Flat-rate fines are unfair

The American criminal justice system is biased in many ways against the lower classes. Flat-rate criminal fines, for example, are patently regressive. Low-income people suffer more financial strain from fines, and are more likely to be ticketed or arrested in the first place.

For many poor people, it’s a cycle they can’t escape. For example, if you can’t afford car repairs, you are much more likely to get pulled over for speeding or a broken tail light. This results in more fines, which means less money to get your car fixed, which means you are still a target for the next cop that comes by.  Also, once a person is pulled over, police are more likely to find drugs or other violations. More fines and court costs.

Progressive fines are fairer and a stronger deterrent

The punishment should fit the crime, right? The punishment should deter others, right? This is true for jail or prison time. But it is not true for criminal fines and traffic citations. There is no incentive to abide by the speed limit if you can easily afford a ticket. It only becomes a problem if you accumulate enough citations to trigger license suspension.

Finland, Argentina, Germany and other countries use progressive fines. Rather than a fixed fee, criminal fines are levied as a percentage of income. This system has three potential advantages:

  • It seems fair – The doctor and the janitor both feel the pinch for the same offense.
  • It increases revenue – High earners would owe higher fines and are more likely pay.
  • It deters crime – Scofflaws would think twice if the fine costs thousands of dollars.

There could still be a cap. A million-dollar fine for a misdemeanor or traffic violation is excessive even for the uber-rich. But the current system unfairly burdens low earners and lets high earners off too easy. Several studies indicate that wealthier people are, on average,  more likely to violate traffic laws and engage in unethical and criminal behavior. It doesn’t help that there’s little incentive to follow the law.

Crazy idea or sounds about right?

Do you think fines should be scaled to what you earn? Or do you think that progressive fines are just a tax-the-rich scheme?


Recent Posts

How can a DUI conviction impact my commercial driver’s license?

On Behalf of Ryan Beasley Law | Apr 8, 2022 | Drunk Driving | Commercial vehicles are a common sight on the South Carolina roads. Trucks go to, from and through the state delivering and carting items that are vital to everyday life. This can include food, materials,...

What defenses are there for domestic violence charges?

Every relationship has times when you and your partner will disagree. An argument can feel very after both parties have had a chance to cool off than it does while it is happening. In some cases, a disagreement can get out of hand or misinterpreted, leaving both...

How a DUI can threaten your college education

College is an exciting time for young adults. Newfound independence often comes with having to make important decisions on your own, including whether to drink and drive. Unfortunately, millions of college students choose to drive while intoxicated. While you may be...

Bill could lead to harsher penalties after drug overdoses

In South Carolina and across the United States, opioids are garnering significant attention. This is understandable given the number of people who are having problems with these types of drugs. Specifically, fentanyl is drawing scrutiny from state and federal law...

Do you know the importance of jury selection in your case?

There’s a lot to consider when building your criminal defense. While you may want to work with prosecutors early on to try to mitigate the fallout from your case, and you certainly want to gather evidence that contradicts the prosecution’s case, you can’t neglect the...

Do You Need Legal Advice? Don’t Wait.

Get Help Now


Visit Our VIDEO CENTER To Find Out More